With timely themes and complex characters, and focusing on the desires, flaws, dreams, and relationships between many different types of women across several decades, this will be perfect for book clubs.
EVERYTHING LOST RETURNS
by Sarah Domet
Flatiron Books/SMP, February 2026
It’s 1910 and Opal, on the run from her abusive husband, has become an Earthshine girl—working in a factory owned by the illustrious Tuttle family to make the extremely popular Earthshine soap. Despite her newfound financial independence, Opal can’t help but notice that many of the Earthshine girls are falling sick, and they all suffer the same symptoms—is it possible that the soap, and the Tuttle family, could be responsible?
Meanwhile, in 1986, struggling soap opera actress Nona Dixon owes everything to Bertie Tuttle, who put Nona’s face on Earthshine soap when she was a child and made her a star. But when Nona starts doing some digging on her benefactor, she begins to uncover a dark history surrounding Bertie, Opal, and the soap that binds all three women together.
Gorgeously written and intricately constructed, EVERYTHING LOST RETURNS is a story of friendship and betrayal, guilt and redemption, and the power we have, in our own small way, to change the course of history
Sarah Domet’s debut novel, The Guineveres, received rave reviews everywhere from The New York Times Book Review to People Magazine to Elle. Sarah lives in Savannah, Georgia.

After spending the summer wracked with guilt about causing the accident that killed her little sister, ambitious gamer and chronic liar Viv returns to Twitch streaming. She never told her parents the truth about the accident, but she hopes that maybe making it big in streaming and giving the money to them is penance enough for her mistakes. The weekend before school starts, Viv finds the perfect horror game to make her Twitch comeback, and during an offline practice run, an NPC asks Viv for a secret. She decides to tell them the truth about her sister’s death since a game could never share her secret—in doing so, she accidentally welcomes a demonic mimic into her life. No one believes Viv when she tells them about her evil doppelganger. Viv has lied to get her best friend’s sympathy and has spread rumors for attention, so why should anyone trust her now? The only person who believes her is Ash, a cute social outcast whom Viv once bullied. In trying to clear her name and kill the mimic, Viv discovers that her lies have hurt people who never deserved it, herself included.
When Nancy Reddy had her first child, she found herself suddenly confronted with the ideal of a perfect mother—a woman who was constantly available, endlessly patient, and immediately invested in her child to the exclusion of all else. Nancy had been raised by a single working mother, considered herself a feminist, and was well on her way to a PhD. Why did doing motherhood “right” feel so wrong?